I’ve built both. Here’s the comparison nobody else will give you straight.
Cost
For a comparable square footage and finish level, a barndominium runs 10–20% less than a traditional stick-frame home in Eastern Idaho. The savings are in the shell — post-frame goes up faster with less labor than stick framing.
But here’s the catch: if you’re finishing the interior to the same standard, your interior costs are identical. The savings are real but smaller than the internet claims.
Durability
Steel siding and roofing outlast comp shingle and vinyl by 15–20 years. Post-frame structures handle Idaho snow loads with less framing material. Both are fine if engineered correctly. A poorly built barndominium fails the same way a poorly built house does.
Resale value
This is where barndominiums lose. In Rigby and Idaho Falls, traditional homes appraise based on comps that exist. Barndominium comps are thin. Banks know it, appraisers know it, future buyers know it.
If you plan to sell in 5–10 years, build traditional. If you’re building your forever home on family land, the barndominium economics make sense.
Lifestyle fit
If you work out of your shop — contractor, mechanic, woodworker, hobbyist with serious tools — a barndominium is a no-brainer. The shop is 20 feet from your kitchen. You’re not driving to a separate building in February at 6 a.m.
If you don’t need a shop, you’re building a barndominium for aesthetics. That’s a valid reason but it’s pure preference, not value.
My honest recommendation
Build a barndominium if all three are true: (1) you need real shop space, (2) you’re staying long-term, (3) you have land that already has utilities or you’ve budgeted for them. Otherwise, a traditional home will serve you better.
Not sure which makes sense for your situation? Talk to us →
Leave a Reply